Be Excellent To Each Other

Let's try that again.


[playerlist]
KovacsC
Saturnalian
zaphod79
Cras
Grim...
ApplePieOfDestiny
Morte
Squirt
[/playerlist]

Day ends at 10pm Friday.

8 people. 5 votes needed.

Haha! So they either hit Aragorn or Gimli did his super-protect, if we have a Gimli?

[vote:KovacsC] for the same reasons as yesterday. Nobody jumped on to force a lynch, as far as I'm concerned that's prime bad guy sign.

I am still a good guy.

Go on then. It's the closest we have to progress unless Cras is bad. [vote: KovacsC]

Kovacs is not one for role claims , so yesterday was one of two things

1) He was actually just being honest and is is Boromir , in which case he should be dead by now anyway
2) He was prompted to role claim as Boromir when voted for by his fellow wraiths

I'm happy to vote for him but i don't want the day to be over that quickly - can we get at least get some people talking ?

If the baddies know who Aragorn is then they can just night murder everyone else until they're certain of a lynching majority, right?

There'd be no particular reason to kill him over night though? They'd be better off trying to get a potential Gimli by picking someone else. Of course, they may have tried to kill him and been blocked by an actual Gimli.

1) I still reckon Kovacs was telling the truth.

2) I reckon there's probably 2 baddies (main and/or hunter) hence they didn't have the numbers to jump on bandwagon vote when there were two opportunities available - myself and Kovacs having two votes.

3) OR there were baddies in both votes so, assuming Kovacs IS a goodie for the purpose of this, potential baddies are:

a) Zaphod
b) Cras
c) Grim...

3) Cras insisting on voting for Kovacs off the bat reeks of scummy.

So I'm going to say [vote: Cras] for reasons: a) Trooper thought he was bad; b) He voted for Kovacs yesterday; c) He's voted for Kovacs even though there was no counterclaim; d) He's voted for Kovacs again without any discussion or evidence to show Kovacs is lying; e) come on, he's mostly a baddun right? Probably.

My mind hasn't changed since yesterday. [vote:KovacsC]


It really needs to end in a lynch this time.

A) This makes no sense. I voted for Kovacs immediately because we were trying to lynch him yesterday but his scummy mates didn't join the vote. Today we're in exactly the same position, so same vote.

B)People pick 0-1 roles to roleclaim deliberately to avoid counterclaims. They're only marginally more believable than a townie roleclaim.

C) Given my immunity appears to no longer be useful, hi. I'm Aragorn. Now lynch Kov please.

[vote:Cras] as he is trying to lynch a good guy

LOL

You and your band of baddies are.

Even if I was wrong about you, your next move would be to persuade me, not vote for me. Did you just ignore me saying I'm Aragorn?

If you are Aragorn you are lynching a good guy.
Would strider do that.

I did drop hints on Friday.

You're on three votes. If you were a good guy the bad guys would vote for you right now and immediately win the game. They have not done so. Funny, that.

Or you buggered up during the night vote.

So given no counterclaim i'm fine with Cras being Aragorn , do you get told if you were attacked last night ?

Lord of the Scum: Day Five
VOTE UPDATE

cras: 2 (Saturnalian, KovacsC)
kovacsc: 3 (Cras, ApplePieOfDestiny, Grim...)

Not voted: 3 (zaphod79, morte, squirt)

With 8 players alive, 5 votes are required for a lynch, and 5 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

I'm happy to put the vote in now - but again we have time to talk - is there anything else to cover right now ?

Sat voting for Cras now , and showing up yesterday when called out for not showing up has him as next on my list

Nope

No one knew he was Aragon and it's not like he's got any magical powers or knowledge that others don't. He could be wrong about Kovacks just as anyone else. I'll follow him this one time but if he's wrong then don't blame me for jumping on this vote.

[vote: kovacsc]

He is wrong. But will be too late if I die

Yes he could be wrong but i'm happier to follow someone who is a 'known' good person than some other random person that I cant trust.

Also for anyone else be careful since Kov is now one vote away from being lynched - again if we want to talk anything out this is our chance

He's not a known goodie - we haven't heard from every player in here and there could be a counterclaim.

But your quite happy to put Kov on one vote away from death ?

I've already said I'll give him the benefit of the doubt, but you're acting like his word is gospel which, I'd suggest, is flawed cause he knows as much as us.

Not much point in leaving the day 'open' if no one is going to talk in here

You might as well call it cause there doesn't appear to be anyone around to participate. We can then review things tomorrow when everyone will mysteriously show up.

I think Morte or Squirt are baddies, as they have not joined in with any discussions. I think we will time out again and hand the game to the baddies

Totally broken logic. If you were a good guy and they were bad guys they would just vote for you right now and WIN THE GAME.

*note by bad guys I mean wraiths here. I'm sort of ignoring Saruman's army, if they exist.

The only reason i've not put the final vote in for you is because there are people who have not participated - its not going to time out (unless others change their vote).

I agree that it does not look like this is doing us any good so i'll give it a little while longer and then vote for Kov

well I think we are going to time out again...

I'm kinda stumped - however, we gondorians have to lynch someone, as the wraiths are certain to kill someone tonight.

"today" finishes at 22:00 tomorrow night - we have over over 34 hours to go



http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

You need one more vote to be lynched

So this is not getting us anywhere - lets move on to the next day and see what happens overnight

[vote: kovacsc]

Lord of the Scum: Day Five
VOTE UPDATE

cras: 1 (KovacsC)
kovacsc: 5 (Cras, ApplePieOfDestiny, Saturnalian, Grim..., zaphod79)

Not voted: 2 (morte, squirt)

With 8 players alive, 5 votes are required for a lynch, and 5 nolynch votes are required to not lynch anybody.

http://www.beexcellenttoeachother.com/counter/

"You do not simply lynch Boromir!" screams KovacsC, but that is indeed what you do.

KovacsC was Boromir

"Oh" says Craster, who was indeed Aragorn.

He turns to see Zaphod79 on the ground, his neck snapped, the One Ring of Power on the ground next to him.

zaphod79 was Frodo

Cras stumbles over two more bodies. Squirt and applepieofdoom.

Squirt was a Gondorian.

Applepieofdoom was a member of Saruman's Army.

Grim... attacks! His swords clash with those of Cras.

Grim... was the Ringwraith Soldier

Cras fights him off well. He is getting the upper hand, but then Morte attacks too! It's always the quiet ones...

Morte was the Ringwraith Hunter

Still, Cras is Aragorn dammit, and he can take two Ringwraiths.

Apart from there are three, and the leader quietly sneaks up from behind and slices Cras's throat.

Saturnalian was the Ringwraith Leader

The Ringwraiths have won! Sauron is Lord of Middle Earth!

WRAITH HI5!

\o/

o/

I told them Kovacks was telling the truth. Tch.

Yes I was, why role claim Boromir!!

HAHAHA Brilliant

Zaphod

what? why didn't it go to night actions?

Nope... I got lynched.

Which I said was a bad idea.

It was 3 baddies, 3 goodies, and a cult recruit at the end of the day.

ASSUMING the baddies killed anyone except Aragorn overnight there was no way for the goodies to then reach a majority lynch, so it would have gone to another night phase, etc. etc.

Sorry brother Nazgul regarding my tardiness voting, luckily it wasn't required.